First, We Do Harm: Obtaining Informed Consent for Surgical Procedures

  • Curt Tribble Division of Cardiac Surgery, University of Virginia Health System, Charlottesville, Virginia, USA
  • Walker Julliard Division of Cardiac Surgery, University of Virginia Health System, Charlottesville, Virginia, USA

Abstract

Although many believe that the phrase “First, do no harm” was part of the Hippocratic Oath, in fact it was not. This phrase, often written in Latin (“Primum non Nocere”), seems to have first appeared in medical writing in the 17th century. However, it is obvious that many therapeutic interventions do cause at least some harm with hopes of benefitting patients in the long run. This balancing of initial harm in hope of eventual benefit is never more apparent than in the case of invasive procedures, though other examples abound, such as the administration of chemotherapy. The ethical concept of nonmaleficence, which traces its origins to the concept of primum non nocere, accurately acknowledges the concept of the need to strive to do more good than harm. Thus, it is apparent that, in a surgical operation, the surgeon is proposing to cause harm, initially, to the patient in hopes of creating an outcome that results in more good than harm. Therefore, the process of obtaining consent from the patient for a surgical operation acknowledges the fact that harm will, in fact, be inflicted on that patient, with the hope that, on balance, this harm will result in a greater overall good for the patient. It is for this reason that the modern concepts of informed consent have developed.

References

A good time to reflect on the wisdom that was Woody [Hayes] [blog]. Bucknuts. [accessed 2019 Sep 7]. https://247sports.com/college/ohio-state/Board/120/Contents/A-good-time-to-reflect-on-the-wisdom-that-was-Woody-110052113/.

Best Case/Worst Case (BC/WC) communication tool - whiteboard video. [accessed 2019 Sep 7]. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FnS3K44sbu0.

Bone R. 1997. Benediction: a farewell to my medical colleagues. J Crit Illn 12:439-40.

Bowler K. 2018. Everything happens for a reason: and other lies I’ve loved. New York: Random House.

Charles Spurgeon quotes: [on anxiety]. BrainyQuote. [accessed 2019 Sep 7]. https://www.brainyquote.com/quotes/charles_spurgeon_132220.

Duke A. 2018. Thinking in bets: making smarter decisions when you don’t have all the facts. New York: Portfolio/Penguin.

[Focusing of the mind]. AZ Quotes. [accessed 2019 Sep 7]. https://www.azquotes.com/quote/1396278 Twain.

Gizzi C. 2016. 13 Beautiful Maya Angelou quotes on living courageously. Fearless Soul. [accessed 2019 Sep 7]. https://iamfearlesssoul.com/13-beautiful-maya-angelou-quotes-on-living-courageously/.

Hobson’s choice. [accessed 2019 Sep 7]. The Phrase Finder. https://www.phrases.org.uk/meanings/hobsons-choice.html.

Jones JW, McCullough LB. 2014. Is “your only hope” medical treatment choice really a choice? J Vasc Surg 60:1083-4.

Jones JW, McCullough LB. 2015. To treat or not to treat: on what should surgical therapy be based? J Vasc Surg 62:1658-9.

Jones JW, McCullough LB. 2015. What is meant by high-risk consent? J Vasc Surg 62:510-1.

McCullough LB, Jones JW, Brody BA. 1998. Surgical ethics. New York: Oxford University Press.

Meador CK. 2018. A little book of doctor rules III: for Oslerian clinicians. New rev. ed. [place unknown]: [Clifton K. Meador].

Hobson’s choice. c2019. Merriam-Webster. [accessed 2019 Sep 8]. https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/Hobson’s%20choice.

Philosophy 102: introduction to philosophical inquiry: Pascal’s wager. [accessed 2019 Sep 8]. https://philosophy.lander.edu/intro/pascal.html.

John Prine lyrics: “Angel from Montgomery.” AZLyrics. [accessed 2019 Sep 7]. https://www.azlyrics.com/lyrics/johnprine/angelfrommontgomery.html.

Richardson JD. 2018. Recovering from an operation. J Am Coll Surg 228:310-1.

Rosenbaum L. 2019. Cursed by knowledge. N Engl J Med 380:786-90.

Sadler GR, Huang JT, Padden CA, et al. 2001. Bringing health care information to the deaf community. J Cancer Educ 16:105-8.

Simon & Garfunkel lyrics: “The Boxer.” AZLyrics. [accessed 2019 Sep 7]. https://www.azlyrics.com/lyrics/simongarfunkel/theboxer.html.

Taylor LJ, Nabozny MJ, Steffens NM, et al. 2017. A framework to improve surgeon communication in high-stakes surgical decisions: Best Case/Worst Case. JAMA Surg 152:531-8.

Tribble C. 2016. Gimme 3 Steps: (with a nod to an American rock song from the 1970s). Heart Surg Forum 19:E80-1.

Tribble C. 2017. Grandmother rules: crucial conversations with patients and families. Heart Surg Forum 20:E2-6.

Tribble C. 2017. Knockin’ on Heaven’s Door: end of life decisions and discussions. Heart Surg Forum 20:E111-5.

Tribble C. 2019. You are the perfect age: an inquiry into surgical ethics during the arc of a career. Heart Surg Forum 22:E50-6.

William Osler quotes: [on being a great physician]. BrainyQuote. [accessed 2019 Sep 7]. https://www.brainyquote.com/quotes/william_osler_386616.

Woo YJ, Handy JR, Sade RM. 2019. First in line for robotic surgery: would you want to know? J Thorac Cardiovasc Surg 157:1934-40.

Published
2019-10-01
How to Cite
Tribble, C., & Julliard, W. (2019). First, We Do Harm: Obtaining Informed Consent for Surgical Procedures. The Heart Surgery Forum, 22(5), E423-E428. https://doi.org/10.1532/hsf.2743
Section
Articles